no_time_to_study

Active recall vs rereading: what the research says

By updated · 5 min read

Short answer: Active recall (testing yourself) beats rereading for anything you need to remember later: in a classic experiment, rereading won on a test 5 minutes later, but self-testing won after 2 days and after a week.

What is active recall?

Active recall means pulling information out of your memory instead of putting it back in. Answering a practice question with your notes closed is active recall. Reading the same notes again is not. The effort of remembering is the point: each time you retrieve something, it gets easier to retrieve next time.

The experiment

Students read short passages. Some then reread them; others took recall tests on them instead, with no feedback. On a test 5 minutes later, the rereaders did better. On tests 2 days and a week later, the students who had tested themselves remembered substantially more (Roediger & Karpicke, 2006).

Exams are days or weeks after you study, not 5 minutes. That's the whole argument in one line.

Why rereading feels better anyway

In the same study, rereading made students more confident they'd remember the material. Familiar text reads smoothly, and smooth feels like knowing. Testing yourself feels harder because you find out what you don't know. That discomfort is useful information, not a sign it isn't working.

What the big review found

A review of ten common study techniques rated two as most useful: practice testing and distributed practice (spreading study over time). Rereading, highlighting and summarising were rated low (Dunlosky et al., 2013).

Spacing multiplies the effect of testing. A review of 317 experiments found that coming back to material after a gap beats cramming it all at once, and that the best gap gets longer the longer you need to remember (Cepeda et al., 2006).

How to do active recall properly

  1. Close the source first. Answer from memory, even if you're not sure.
  2. Then check against the source. Find the exact slide or page so you correct the right thing.
  3. Track what you miss. A mistakes list is your most valuable study material.
  4. Come back later. Retest your misses the next day, then a few days after that.
  5. Mix topics. Exams don't ask questions in lecture order.

Questions, answered.

Are flashcards active recall?

Yes, if you answer before you flip the card. Flipping straight away and nodding along turns them back into rereading.

How often should I review?

Come back to material after a gap, and make the gaps longer as it sticks: for example the next day, then a few days later, then a week later. The closer the exam, the shorter the gaps you can use.

Does active recall work for maths and science?

Yes. Solving practice problems without looking at the worked solution is active recall. Read the solution only after you've tried.

Sources

  1. Roediger & Karpicke (2006), Test-Enhanced Learning: Taking Memory Tests Improves Long-Term Retention, Psychological Science
  2. Dunlosky et al. (2013), Improving Students' Learning With Effective Learning Techniques, Psychological Science in the Public Interest
  3. Cepeda et al. (2006), Distributed Practice in Verbal Recall Tasks: A Review and Quantitative Synthesis, Psychological Bulletin

Do all this without the setup.

Upload your lecture slides and No Time to Study builds the lessons, the practice and the mock exam. It's in early access: join the list and your first lecture is free.

Free first lecture when we open. Launch emails only, unsubscribe anytime.